It’s a Sin to Destroy Lovely Places

Musical accompaniment: Adagio un poco moto – III. Rondo. Allegro (excerpt) from Piano Concerto No. 5 in E-flat composed by Ludwig van Beethoven

 

Today I want to profile the beautiful old Public Library of Cincinnati. It was completed in 1874 and drew people from around the world to marvel at it.

From the outside, it’s a nice building but the exterior gives you no sense of how magnificent the interior was, with its spiral staircases, marble floors, immense skylights, and treasure troves of important books.

 

Part of the reason the library was so spectacular was that the building was originally intended to be an opera house. The owner died while it was under construction and the city purchased the lot and the building. They hired a new architect, James W. McLaughlin, to turn it into a city library.

wikimedia

wikimedia

wikimedia

I love these checkerboard marble floors!

wikimedia

If I were a ghost, it is just the sort of place I’d like to haunt.

The building was opened to the public in 1870 and officially completed in 1874. At that time, Harper’s Weekly profiled the building:

The whole interior construction of this hall is of iron, with the exception of the book-shelves, which are of ash. The light, graceful columns which support the roof are of wrought iron. Sixteen feet above the main ceiling is a lantern of iron and glass, covering the entire space. There are 32,000 glass prisms in the lantern, set in cast iron after the HYATT pattern, which is used in sidewalk pavements to light basements.

The roof and all the floors are laid on iron girders, spanned by corrugated boiler plates, which are filled with cement and covered with iron. In the eastern corners are two square stacks of brick, one for an elevator and the other for ventilation.

Through the centre of the latter passes the iron chimney of the steam-boilers in the basement. Four dumb-waiters extend from the lower floor to the upper alcoves, which, with the elevator, are worked by hydraulic power.

The building was more than a beautiful place. It met very specific needs, like this reading room for the blind.

wikimedia

The newspaper archive room:

wikimedia

The useful arts room housed many rare and valuable manuscripts.

wikimedia

Audubon room. My friend Alexandra tells me these were first editions!

wikimedia

wikimedia

The catalogue department. One of my dreams is to own a library card catalogue. I know they’re expensive and heavy and difficult to come by but I really, really want one.

wikimedia

The Training room:

wikimedia

I’ll grudgingly admit the building had challenges. The basement was prone to flooding, the natural light was lacking, and there was no air conditioning. People had legitimate worries about a fire. Fire destroyed many beautiful buildings in that era, leading to horrible tragedies with high death tolls. Also, the library was created to hold 300,000 books and by the time it closed there were 1.5 million books!

Nevertheless, it’s a sin to destroy something so beautiful. Cincinnati’s lovely opera house library was demolished in 1955 when a newer, modern library was built nearby. Even its demolition was interesting. The vice president of the Cleveland Wrecking Company, which was hired to carry out this wicked deed, said the old library would “die hard.” He meant that it was built so well and so sturdily, it would be difficult to take down. And it was! It took three months to demolish it and required a large crew of approximately 60 men, in addition to the heavy wrecking equipment.

In its place today is an office and a parking garage. It’s hard to believe such a wonderful place was deliberately destroyed. It’s a theme I harp on too often but I really believe that people behave better and live better lives in beautiful surroundings.

This library card reminded me of another Ohio case–that of disgraced professor Orville Marsh, whose criminal career was exclusively related to library books!

wikimedia

4 thoughts on “It’s a Sin to Destroy Lovely Places

  1. The carving on the ends of those beautiful bookshelves were amazing! I love old libraries and those old card catalog cases, too! It is sinful to destroy beautiful old buildings!

    Liked by 2 people

  2. I find it interesting that the Cincinnati Public Library was not a stand-alone building. The outside doesn’t do justice to the beauty of its interior. I wish a philanthropist had saved the building.

    The first U. S. public library is considered to be the Franklin Public Library in Franklin, Massachusetts, established in 1790 with the donation of books from Benjamin Franklin. Another individual who had a significant impact on the public library system throughout the United State was Andrew Carnegie, the Father of the American Steel Industry.

    Carnegie sold his fully-integrated steel company, Carnegie Steel, to J. P. Morgan, the very wealthy New York banker. It was Morgan who named his newly acquired steel company United States Steel Corporation. That sale allowed Carnegie to become a philanthropist who most know funded Carnegie Hall, Carnegie-Mellon University, Carnegie Institute, etc. But most do not know that Andrew Carnegie played a significant role in the spread of the Public Library System in the United States and other countries.

    Because of his limited formal schooling, Andrew Carnegie knew the importance of education and books. Carnegie funded 2,500 libraries between 1883 and 1929, that were both public and university libraries, in the U.S. and other countries. The first Carnegie Library was constructed in Braddock, PA, and opened in 1889.

    Braddock Carnegie Library, May 2010

    Braddock Carnegie Library, Wikipedia

    In total, Carnegie funded 1,689 libraries in the United States; 660 in the United Kingdom and Ireland; 125 in Canada; and, 25 in other countries such as Australia, South Africa, New Zealand, Serbia, Belgium, France, the Caribbean, Mauritius, Malaysia and Fiji. Acutely aware of segregation in the Souther States, Carnegie funded libraries for Black citizens in Houston, TX and Savannah, GA. When a young boy, Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas spent many hours in the Savannah library before desegregation.

    By the time the last Carnegie grant was made there were 3,500 libraries throughout in the United States, half built by Carnegie. Carnegie libraries were constructed in a variety of architectural styles: Beaux-Arts, Italian Renaissance, Baroque, Classical Revival and Spanish Colonial. In his native Scotland the style was Scottish Baronial.

    Liked by 2 people

    • I sure wish Carnegie had purchased this library. He could have maybe repurposed it, provided the architecture was left intact. We don’t have enough beautiful buildings. You’re right it is interesting it wasn’t a standalone building! Good point!

      Like

Leave a reply to judymcneel Cancel reply