Macie Colbert’s “Bittersweet Revenge”

Nicola Di Crescenzo
Latest posts by Nicola Di Crescenzo (see all)

“Grace Roberts, 22, art model, whom real name was Mazie Colbert and whose face, pictured in hundreds of advertisements of women’s clothing, was known all over the world.”

That statement was on page one of The Cleveland Press, January 2, 1917, as the opening line inside a box with the heading: “The Crime In Brief.” “The Brief” summarized the key elements of the murder of a renowned 1917 “art model,” the young and beautiful Grace Roberts, a.k.a Mazie Colbert.

“The Crime In Brief” identified “The Victim,” Miss Grace Roberts, who was found by police in her room at a Philadelphia apartment house. Papers across America reported the murder of the well known model living in the City of Brotherly Love, pronouncing that her notoriety immediately placed every prominent person on “a person of interest” list.

The Cleveland Press, January 2, 1917 – newspapers.com

The Cleveland Press, January 2, 1917 – newspapers.com

Grace Roberts’ murder was a news topic for days in every major city in America.

The Buffalo Enquirer, January 3, 1917 – newspaper.com

An image of the young woman accompanied almost every story.

The Cleveland Press, January 2, 1917 – newspapers.com

The Brookville Republican, Brookville, Pennsylvania, in its story, “Romance and Tragedy of Grace Roberts, Slain Model, told readers, “Really to understand the significance of Mazie Colbert’s career, it is necessary to go back to the days when she was the much envied belle of the little town of Kane, PA. There the story starts with everything, it would seem, that the gods could give a girl to make her happy.”

According to The Brookville Republican, “Mazie Colbert was beautiful. She had jet black hair and dark, alluring eyes – eyes that were fringed with curling black lashes.” The paper opined that she was, of course, a popular girl, with a life written in happiness. And, furthermore, “Only a girl can really understand what it means to be the prettiest, most sought after girl in town. It means the realization of a girl’s splendid childhood dreams of success.”

Twice-A-Week Messenger, Owensboro, Kentucky, January 10, 1917 – newspaper.com

Chapter one of Mazie Colbert’s life can only be written in the most delightful terms. Boys galore arrived at he house wanting to take her “to a dance or skating or driving.” The mayor of the young woman’s hometown of Kane, Pennsylvania, James F. Woods, is quoted in the newspapers as saying, “I blame Mazie’s mother for all this,” he declared emphatically a few days after learning of the murder. Woods went on to say, “Mazie’s mother never looked back of [sic] this popularity. She was the happiest woman in town when the boys came in droves to the house, always asking for Mazie . . .”

Mayor Woods claimed the “. . . other mothers shook their heads in doubt.” According to the Mayor’s observations, “But Mazie’s mother didn’t seem to realize the danger.” Other mother’s knew “Mazie was getting ‘boy crazy’,” but Mrs. Colbert was oblivious to the danger because “she was so proud of the fact that her girl was the belle of the village, other things did not seem to matter.”

The Brookville paper declared it was “not hard for the people of the small town to patch together the miscellaneous events that made up the glittering futility of this very pretty girl’s career. There were dances in the old days, and Mazie was the best dancer in town. “Mazie was the best skater,” too. Walking through town with a reporter, the mayor commented and pointed, “He was once in love with Mazie, too.”

Moving On To Bigger Things

Mazie became tired or bored with her work in the local parochial school, deciding to move to another town. She was 18; it was 1908. Her best chum, Verne Mahoney, went with her to Erie, Pennsylvania, and that was the beginning of her “career” and the time she changed her name from Mazie Colbert to Grace Roberts. Only those who knew her from Kane knew her real name.

B96.2
Erie, Pennsylvania, State Street North of 10th, 1913 – hagenhistory.org

Part of Panoramic Map, Erie, PA – Library of Congress

Vintage postcard of West 10th Street in Erie, PA with red brick buildings, green trees, and yellow trolley cars.
1917 Erie, Pennsylvania, Postcard

After a year in Erie the two young women relocated to Jamestown, New York. After being arrested for a night fight in the Lolan Building, Grace and Verne left town in the dark of night, skipping out on their bond.

Jamestown, New York, Main Street, 1914 – en.wikipedia.org

That is when the two woman went their separate ways, Verne travelled to Elmira, New York, while Grace relocated to Philadelphia.

Elmira, New York, Main Street, circa 1920 – nyheritage.contentdm.oclc.org

Why Verne decided to go to Elmira, New York, is not established in any record. Elmira was certainly a much less populated. Based on U. S. Census data, Elmira had a population of 37,816, while Philadelphia had a population of 1,657,810. Certainly there had to have been much more opportunities in Philadelphia versus Elmira. And so, Grace latched on to one of those opportunities.

There were seven children in Grace’s family, and she was the youngest. (That may explain Mrs. Colbert’s complacency towards Grace’s activities.) The reporter for the paper deduced that because she was the youngest, the prettiest and very popular, “her mother seemed to take it for granted that she could look after herself.” Yet the reporter wrote that, “Swiftly passing years in Philadelphia tell their own story far better than the imagination can picture it.”

Lizzie Colbert, Mazie’s sister, arrived in Philadelphia shortly after her younger sister’s arrival. A few years later the sisters sent for their “aged parents, who sold their home in Kane, broke up the family there and came to Philadelphia join their two daughters.” By that time Grace Roberts had started to earn her own way “having taken a position as manicure in a large department store.” That position evolved into a friendship with an older woman who had a large establishment of her own who came to need another “manicure,” leading to Grace’s ever widening circle of friends and beaus.

Mazie’s Evolution

Grace Robert’s popularity attracted many rich and prominent men, and her life became more than anything she ever dared to dream would come to her during her days in Kane, Pennsylvania. As told by The Brookville Republican, “There was no limit to the wild gaiety of the days that followed,” because of her beauty and popularity. According to that same newspaper, “And Grace Robert’s leadership through it all was no fancied affair.” The story further claimed that “. . . you can hear today of her beauty, her ready wit and her unusual gift of mimicry. This girl had little education, but she knew how to read people instantly and well. She could absorb the meaning and force of things they said a she never forgot. A wonderful memory was her asset.” Apparently, people, especially men, were like putty in her hands. One objective reporter had to admit that regardless what people thought of Grace Robert’s career, she cleverly included men known to have a national reputation as thinkers and men of power in professional and financial circles.

Due to her developed art of listening, which she cultivated very early in her career, she became a brilliant conversationalist, so men never found her boring. Grace became known as having intelligence, ability and great feminine charm. Her popularity was her asset and she knew how to use it. Those traits led to her opening her own “manicuring shop” on the sixth floor of the Keith Building and her coterie of men followed her there. She then became an entirely independent businesswoman, no longer required to share profits.

ChatGPT Generated Depiction of a 1908 Manicure Shop

With her success came a little apartment at the corner of Fifteenth and Popular Streets. Furnishing the apartment were days of joy for Grace Roberts, and everything was supposedly “exquisitely furnished in quiet good taste.” After that came a car, a roadster, to add to her personal conveniences. Mazie Colbert, a.k.a. Grace Roberts, had made it!

Grace Roberts infatuated many men, one was Charles D. Kaier, the son of a wealthy owner of a brewery, who was also known as “Champagne Charlie.” Even publicly recognized political leaders were seen pick her up at her apartment. But one young man in particular who appealed to her years earlier – Bernard Wesley Lewis – re-entered her life. Lewis, the son of a retired Pittsburgh lawyer and goal company owner, was a young man with social status and financial means. His family had a home in “The Quaker City” and he spent time in there. Mr. Lewis had given a $400 diamond ring to Grace years earlier, intending to marry her. Now, seven years later, Bernard was married to another woman and had a child . . . and continued to have an affection for Grace.

Story photo of Lewis, The Pittsburgh Post, January 5, 1917 – newspapers.com

Mrs. Betty W. Lewis, The Philadelphia Inquirer, January 7, 1917 – newspapers.com

Lewis found himself in financial difficulties at the end of December 1916. Police pieced together that sometime on Friday, December 29, 1916, Lewis went to Grace’s apartment to demand the return of the $400 diamond ring he had given her years earlier. That demand led to a heated argument and eventual physical retaliation by Lewis.

Based on the crime scene, police concluded that Lewis struck Roberts with a blunt instrument that caused perfuse bleeding, but did not kill her. As she attempted to crawl to the phone to call for help, Lewis realize she could identify him to police, a position he did not want to be in because of public disgrace.

Crime Scene Photo, Grace Roberts’ Bedroom, The Philadelphia Inquirer, Saturday, January 6, 1917 – newspapers.com

Police deduced that Lewis decided to finish the job he started by strangling Grace (after already fractureing her skull) and then drag her lifeless body onto her bed. Lewis hurriedly left the apartment to return to his family’s Philadelphia home and then leave the City.

The Pittsburgh Press, January 5, 1917 – newspapers.com

Sidebar: Investigators and newspapers reported that seven years earlier Mazie Colbert was “. . . a waitress in the Exchange Hotel in Warren [Pennsylvania]. There she fell in love with a young millionaire, member of one of the wealthiest and most prominent families in northwest Pennsylvania.” According to January 3, 1916 issue of The Omaha Daily News, Omaha, Nebraska, the couple planned on being married. But the “social set” of Pittsburgh and Lewis’ parents (Wenman and Elizabeth Lewis) refused to accept her as a proper match, forcing the couple to end their relationship and marriage plans. (Wenman A. Lewis was a prominent Pittsburgh lawyer who retired from his law practice to become a successful coal company owner.) That same paper reported, “They will pay; I’ll make them or die in the attempt, Mazie is alleged to have told a girl friend before she left Warren to embark willfully upon the course that brought death to her . . . ” (Warren, Pennsylvania, is about 21 miles, as the crow-flies, from Kane, Pennsylvania.)

Telling police about Grace’s relationship with Bernard, “Her friends . . . declared that it was a real love match – on the part of each. Because of the refusal of his family to permit the marriage, Mazie declared vengeance. She swore she was through with the path of rectitude. A few days later she left Warren, went to Erie and was initiated by a woman notorious throughout the east, into baiting, bleeding, heart-breaking and home-rending game that she pursued for the next six years in Philadelphia.” (That statement is not 100% correct; Mazie went to Erie, Pennsylvania, then Jamestown, New York, before going to Philadelphia.)

Developing background facts of Mazie’s murder, Philadelphia police learned from friends that 6 weeks earlier Mazie admitted she was “entertained” in New York by Bernard Lewis and that the day of the murder he “unwittingly” involved Misses Ethel and Mabel Kyle, both public school teachers and of “high repute,” into his foray against Grace Roberts. The two women shared a cab with Lewis who wanted to go to the Wilton Apartments, and testified to police that he departed the cab at that location. As the man exited the cab at the apartment building the night of the murder, the sisters reported, “The man told the chauffeur to wait, but he never reappeared.”

Sisters, Ethel and Mabel Kyle, Photo from The Pittsburgh Press, January 7, 1917 – newspapers.com

Physical evidence was also found by police when assessing the murder scene. A man’s shirt collar, sold as a separate piece of a man’s shirt in 1917, was found in Grace’s apartment stained with her blood. When the murder hit the newspapers the next day as sales woman remembered a man matching the police description of Bernard W. Lewis who she sold a shirt and collar to the day of the murder. The shirt he was wearing was stained with a red substance and needed to be replaced. She related her story to the detectives investigating the murder.

When police did not find Lewis at the family’s Philadelphia home, they tracked him to a hotel in Atlantic City, New Jersey. Lewis replied through the room’s door in which he was staying when police knocked, but did not immediately open it to allow entry. Before the police could enter the room a gun shot echoed into the hall. Upon entering the room the police found Lewis, in the bathtub with a gun shot from a 22 caliber rifle, still in his hands. Sadly, Lewis’ remedy to his predicament was suicide.

The Boston Globe, January 5, 1917, Pages One and Three – newspapers.cm

Not mentioned in The Boston Globe Story is a letter Bernard wrote on December 17, 1916, long before his actual suicide and the murder of Mazie Colbert. It was to his best friend, James S. McFadyan, the general manager of the Pittsburgh Stock Yards, in which he bemoaned his actions, expressed his apology for what he was about to do, ending with, “This is my last request of you.” The request is that McFadyan, as long as he is alive, insure that no harm comes to his wife and child, and to counsel his wife, Betty, of the potential “pitfalls ahead of her so she may miss them.” That request of McFadyan also extended to Bernard’s parents.

The Pittsburgh Press, January 7, 1917 – newspapers.com

Moral standards of the time, as one might expect, resulted in public criticism of Mazie Colbert’s lifestyle.

The Omaha Daily News, January 5, 1917 – newspapers.com

Twice-A-Week “The Messenger,” Owensboro, Kentucky , January 10, 1917 – newspapers.com

So in the end, the love and lives of two young people were extinguished. The cast system carried over from earlier times reared its ugly head and the social mores and cultural perceptions that surrounded the cast prevented two lovers from marrying. It is only fitting to end this post with a final picture of Mazie Colber, a.k.a. Grace Roberts.

The Boston Globe, January 5, 1917 – newspapers.com

Comments, observations and feedback on this post are, as always, welcomed.

Leave a Reply