Successful 1905 Hoax Still Duping People

/ Kimberly

Have you ever heard the story of The Patient Bullet?

In 1883 in the town of Honey Grove, Texas, Henry Ziegland dumped his fiancé, Maysie Tichnor. She was despondent and committed suicide. Her enraged brother decided Ziegland had to die. He went to Ziegland’s farm and shot the young man who had hurt his sister, then he turned the gun on himself.  

Unbeknownst to the brother, Ziegland did not die. He wasn’t even seriously hurt. The bullet had only grazed him before hitting a tree. Ziegland prospered in life. Twenty years after he dodged a literal bullet, he and his son were cutting firewood. They cut down the tree with the bullet in it but the wood was so tough, it was almost impossible to split it with an axe. So, they bored some holes in the fallen tree and put small amounts of dynamite in the holes. Ziegland and his son moved about 50 feet away and set the explosions off. 

The bullet, which had waited twenty years for Henry Ziegland, was blown out of the tree with great force and the farmer was hit in the left temple, and killed instantly. 

~~~

I love weird historical stories and coincidences. There are a surprising number of them that check out. This story is fairly popular – there are lots of posts about it on the Internet and you can even see pictures of the tree and the bullet. Honey Grove, Texas still exists today.

The story appeared over 100 times in the newspapers, where it was presented as legitimate news, but there is quite a bit of evidence to suggest the story of Henry Ziegland was a hoax.

There is no record of anyone with the names Ziegland or Tichnor or anything similar that ever lived in Honey Grove. No vital records could be found for people who match these dates and descriptions in Texas or any other state.

The story was first published in the Jackson (MS) Evening News in a March 24, 1905 article. It was picked up by several papers, and began, “A marvelous case of punishment on earth for the sins of the flesh occurred in Dryno township, in this county, today. Twenty years ago Henry Ziegland, then a handsome, wealthy young man, jilted beautiful Maysie Tichnor, and the girl committed suicide…”

The first time the story appeared in a newspaper was in Jackson, MS, in 1905

The story disappeared for the better part of the decade, and inexplicably reappeared in 1913. The names were unchanged but the newspapers still ran the story as current news. This time around, the story got a lot more traction. It ran in newspapers from Edmonton (Canada) to New Orleans to Buffalo.

Another 1913 paper

The success of this hoax is far more impressive than the fabricated story of Henry Ziegland. It was probably started by a couple of teenagers sitting around in 1905 who came up with this funny little story and decided to see if they could dupe a newspaper into publishing it.

Not only were they able to get it published but by 1913, the story was appearing in international newspapers. And over a century later, a lot of people still believe this story is true and continue to spread it. A Google search for “Henry Ziegland bullet” produces over 5,400 results in 0.35 seconds!

21 thoughts on “Successful 1905 Hoax Still Duping People”

    • It is weird to suggest that teenagers made the story up without offering evidence. If you are claiming something is a hoax, which this story may be, why throw further confusion by adding something with nothing to back it? It seems that the debunker is making stuff up.

      Like

      Reply

      • Bro…. Something that cannot be proven, does not need disproving. Being that the story has no real evidence or proof, one can only assume it’s a hoax, if not a hoax then what would you call it? What did the author add to which you are referring?

        Liked by 1 person

        Reply

  2. Pingback: Old Spirituals 2019 Retrospective – Old Spirituals

      • HI, JUST READ YOUR BLOG ON ZIEGLAND. JUST BECAUSE YOU COULDN’T FIND ANY DOCUMENTS DOESN’T DISPROVE THE STORY. THINGS WEREN’T FILED AND STORED AS WELL AS THEY ARE TODAY, PLUS PAPER, ESPECIALLY BACK THEN, DISINTEGRATED PRETTY QUICKLY UNLESS IT WAS VELLUM, ETC. PLUS THE STORY OCCURRED IN 1893 – NOT 1883 – SO YOU REALLY HAVEN’T DISPROVED IT AT ALL. YOU’RE QUITE WELCOME TO YOUR OPINION, BUT JUST BECAUSE YOU DO NOT BELIEVE DOES NOT MEAN THAT AN INCIDENT DID NOT OCCUR. KEEP AN OPEN MIND OR DISPROVE THINGS 100% BEFORE YOU CROW ABOUT IT.

        Like

        Reply

        • Hi Billy, thanks for your comment. It’s true that paper records aren’t always preserved. From the evidence I found, I believe this story is a hoax… but if you find proof it really did happen, I’m definitely interested in seeing it!

          Like

          Reply

        • Something that cannot be proven, does NOT need to be disproven. The lack of evidence proving it’s real, is in itself proof enough that it did not happen, or does not exist. When 2 people or 100 people look inside an empty room, none of them ask for proof that it’s empty because they can all clearly see that it is lacking objects, items, or details. The lack of objects/items/details is the proof that it is empty. So since this story lacks the objects or items or details needed to prove its validity, then one can be assured that it is false, unless the proper objects/items/details are presented to prove otherwise.

          Liked by 1 person

          Reply

  4. Pingback: The 20-Year Flight of the Killer Bullet – Commonplace Fun Facts

  5. Pingback: Peluru yang jitu. – spotsocks

  7. Pingback: La bufala del “proiettile paziente di Ziegland” compie 117 anni -

Share your thoughts on this post